Vatican newspaper ‘forgives’ John Lennon’s Jesus remarks – 22 November 2008

Side-four Apple label of the Beatles’ 1968 White Album, whose fortieth anniversary prompted L’Osservatore Romano’s tribute in 2008

Saturday 22 November 2008 · People and cultural history · John Lennon and The Beatles

John Lennon’s 1966 remark that the Beatles were “more popular than Jesus” returned to the headlines on 22 November 2008, this time in a favourable assessment from the Vatican newspaper. L’Osservatore Romano marked the fortieth anniversary of the White Album by praising the Beatles and treating Lennon’s statement as youthful boasting amid sudden fame.

International reports described the newspaper’s response as forgiveness. The comments appeared in an anniversary article in the Vatican’s semi-official daily, rather than a personal statement by the Pope.

Key facts

Date Saturday 22 November 2008
Publication L’Osservatore Romano
Occasion Fortieth anniversary of The Beatles, commonly called the White Album
Original remark John Lennon’s comments to Maureen Cleave
Original interview publication London Evening Standard, 4 March 1966
2008 response The newspaper dismissed the remark as youthful boasting and praised the Beatles’ musical legacy
UK stereo White Album side-four Apple label, catalogue number PCS 7068, with its six closing tracks
Side-four Apple label of the White Album, first released in the UK on 22 November 1968.

A White Album anniversary tribute

The newspaper’s reassessment coincided with the fortieth anniversary of the White Album’s UK release on 22 November 1968. The double LP, officially titled The Beatles, became the focus of an appreciation of the group’s musical range and lasting influence.

L’Osservatore Romano praised the group’s “unique and strange alchemy of sounds and words” and described the White Album as a “magical musical anthology”. Its assessment reached beyond the old controversy to the continuing appeal of the Lennon–McCartney catalogue.

The newspaper argued that the songs had endured remarkably well in the 38 years since the band’s break-up and had inspired successive generations of pop musicians. Reuters’ report of 22 November 2008 carried both the response to Lennon’s remark and the newspaper’s praise of the Beatles.

What the newspaper said about Lennon

The article placed Lennon’s statement in the context of a young working-class musician confronting extraordinary success. It treated the words as showing off, rather than allowing the controversy to define his musical contribution.

That change of tone produced the widespread headlines that the Vatican had forgiven Lennon. The published response at the centre of those reports was the newspaper’s cultural assessment, written for an album anniversary more than four decades after the original interview.

The original Maureen Cleave interview

The Evening Standard published Maureen Cleave’s profile of Lennon on 4 March 1966. Her interview examined his life away from the stage, including his reading and opinions about religion.

Lennon discussed Christianity’s future and compared its contemporary popularity with that of the Beatles. The short phrase that became notorious was: “We’re more popular than Jesus now.” The comments attracted relatively little controversy in Britain when first published.

The reaction changed after the remarks were republished by the American magazine Datebook in July 1966, shortly before the Beatles’ final US tour.

Record burnings, broadcasting bans and threats

Some American radio stations stopped playing Beatles records. Public record burnings took place, while the Ku Klux Klan organised anti-Beatles demonstrations. The group received death threats during the tour.

The controversy also extended beyond the United States. The Vatican denounced Lennon at the time, and the South African Broadcasting Corporation banned the playing of Beatles songs.

Lennon faced questions about his remarks at a press conference in Chicago. He expressed regret for the offence caused, while explaining the context of the comparison. The band’s final American tour concluded at Candlestick Park in San Francisco on 29 August 1966.

The White Album’s continuing legacy

The 2008 tribute returned attention to an album containing thirty tracks across four sides. Its contrasting styles included acoustic songs, rock performances, music-hall influences and experimental sound work.

For the complete running order, explore our White Album UK tracklist. The original-release anniversary article covers the numbered sleeve, poster and portraits, recording history and mono/stereo editions.

Explore White Album designs

Discover designs connected with the record celebrated in the Vatican newspaper’s anniversary article, or browse the Beatles T-shirts and tops collection.

White Beatles White Album Tracks T-shirt showing four band portraits and song titles on the front, with Beatles lettering on the back
Shop the White Album Tracks T-shirt.
White Beatles socks with black outline portraits of the four band members and Beatles lettering
Explore the White Album Faces Outlines socks.

Frequently asked questions

What happened on 22 November 2008?

International reports highlighted a White Album anniversary article in L’Osservatore Romano that praised the Beatles and dismissed Lennon’s 1966 Jesus remark as youthful boasting.

Why was the story described as the Vatican forgiving Lennon?

News coverage characterised the Vatican newspaper’s sympathetic reassessment as forgiveness. The comments came from the newspaper’s anniversary article.

When were Lennon’s original comments published?

On 4 March 1966, in Maureen Cleave’s Evening Standard interview.

Why did the controversy grow later in 1966?

The remarks were republished in the American magazine Datebook shortly before the Beatles’ US tour, prompting protests and radio bans.

Why did the newspaper discuss the White Album?

22 November 2008 was the fortieth anniversary of its UK release.

What did the newspaper praise?

The Beatles’ combination of sounds and words, the White Album’s musical variety and the lasting influence of the Lennon–McCartney songs.

0 comments

Leave a comment