Paul McCartney announces silent protest track for Is This What We Want? – 17 November 2025

Black-and-white typographic cover of Is This What We Want? by Various Artists

Monday 17 November 2025 | Paul McCartney | Recording announcement

Paul McCartney announced his contribution to the vinyl edition of Is This What We Want? on 17 November 2025. Titled “Bonus Track”, the two-minute, 45-second recording captured an empty studio, with quiet background sounds rather than a conventional song performance.

The album formed part of musicians' campaign against proposed changes to UK copyright rules affecting the use of creative work to train artificial-intelligence systems. McCartney's official announcement described the project as a silent album involving more than 1,000 musicians. The vinyl edition was announced for 8 December 2025 through The state51 Conspiracy.

Announcement facts

Announcement date 17 November 2025
Artist Paul McCartney
Track Bonus Track
Length 2 minutes, 45 seconds
Album Is This What We Want? — Various Artists
Original digital release 25 February 2025
Announced vinyl release 8 December 2025
Vinyl label and distributor The state51 Conspiracy
Charity Help Musicians
Is This What We Want? album cover with large black lettering on a white background
Is This What We Want? — Various Artists.

What is McCartney's Bonus Track?

The recording contains the sounds of an otherwise empty studio. Contemporary descriptions identify quiet hiss and intermittent clattering, with the sound fading in and out. Its near-silence was the point of the contribution: the album used recordings of unoccupied recording and performance spaces as its protest.

McCartney added the piece for the physical edition rather than the original February digital album. His contribution therefore belonged to the later vinyl campaign, announced in November, while the wider project had already been available for several months.

The 17 November news concerned that forthcoming edition. The announcement date and the advertised 8 December release date were separate events.

The musicians' protest album

Is This What We Want? was organised by composer Ed Newton-Rex. Its original programme comprised twelve tracks, with titles that together read: “The British Government Must Not Legalise Music Theft To Benefit AI Companies”.

The organisers said their recordings of empty studios and performance spaces represented the effect they feared the government's proposals would have on musicians' livelihoods. The words in the track titles expressed the campaign's position, while the subdued recordings supplied its musical form.

The project opposed the use of artists' work for AI training without permission. Its proceeds were designated for Help Musicians, the charity supporting people working in music.

The original twelve-track programme

  1. The
  2. British
  3. Government
  4. Must
  5. Not
  6. Legalise
  7. Music
  8. Theft
  9. To
  10. Benefit
  11. AI
  12. Companies

Additional vinyl recording: “Bonus Track” — Paul McCartney, 2:45.

From studio experimentation to a quiet protest

McCartney's contribution used studio ambience rather than a sung lyric or instrumental arrangement. It joined a catalogue that also included tape experiments, improvised recordings and work released under the Fireman name.

On the same date seventeen years earlier, news coverage had focused on McCartney's wish to release Carnival Of Light, the Beatles' 1967 experimental recording. That was a different work with a different purpose, but another occasion when a recording outside the conventional song format became the subject of a McCartney announcement.

Another Beatles-related precedent was John Lennon's “Nutopian International Anthem”, a brief silent track on his 1973 album Mind Games. McCartney's “Bonus Track” instead formed part of the collective 2025 campaign and contained audible room and recording noise.

Paul McCartney merchandise

Explore the Paul McCartney & Wings collection, including designs connected with his solo recordings and Wings catalogue.

McCartney Photo T-shirt

Paul McCartney Photo T-shirt.

Paul McCartney Photo black unisex T-shirt

McCartney II T-shirt

McCartney II light-blue T-shirt.

Paul McCartney II unisex T-shirt

Photo Rose T-shirt

Paul McCartney Photo Rose T-shirt with back print.

Paul McCartney Photo Rose white T-shirt with back print

Frequently asked questions

What did McCartney announce on 17 November 2025?

He announced Bonus Track, his contribution to the vinyl edition of Is This What We Want?

How long is Bonus Track?

Two minutes and 45 seconds.

Is the recording completely silent?

No. It contains quiet studio ambience, including hiss and occasional clattering.

When was the vinyl edition announced for release?

8 December 2025. The original digital album had appeared on 25 February 2025.

What message do the original track titles form?

The British Government Must Not Legalise Music Theft To Benefit AI Companies.

Which charity benefits from the project?

Help Musicians.

Read McCartney's official 17 November announcement and the album campaign's vinyl announcement.


November archive | On This Day | Beatles Knowledge Hub

0 comments

Leave a comment