Beatles download sites remain blocked: BlueBeat injunction reported – 19 November 2009

Green Apple label on side one of the Beatles’ Abbey Road stereo LP, catalogue number PCS 7088

Thursday 19 November 2009 | Beatles catalogue | Digital music and court reporting

Reports on 19 November 2009 confirmed that restrictions on BlueBeat.com and Basebeat.com would continue after a Los Angeles federal judge issued a preliminary injunction. The services had attracted attention by offering Beatles recordings for 25 US cents each.

The court order was dated 18 November. The following day’s coverage described the sites as remaining shut indefinitely, while the injunction itself restrained distribution of the record companies’ recordings pending trial.

The injunction: key facts

On This Day entry 19 November 2009, the reporting date
Court order 18 November 2009
Judge US District Judge John F. Walter
Court US District Court, Central District of California
Sites BlueBeat.com and Basebeat.com
Businessman involved Hank Risan
Record company EMI Group
Advertised Beatles track price 25 US cents
Type of order Preliminary injunction pending trial
Earlier lawsuit Filed on 3 November 2009

From cheap downloads to a federal lawsuit

The controversy began when BlueBeat offered Beatles recordings online before the catalogue’s authorised iTunes launch. EMI filed suit earlier in November to stop the streaming and sale of its recordings.

Our 4 November article on EMI’s BlueBeat lawsuit covers the service’s appearance and the initial dispute. The later injunction continued the restrictions while that litigation remained in progress.

Although Beatles recordings generated much of the publicity, the action also concerned music by other EMI artists. The court order addressed recordings owned or controlled by the plaintiffs, rather than only one Beatles album or song.

Abbey Road stereo LP side-one Apple label, PCS 7088
Apple label on the Abbey Road stereo LP, PCS 7088. Photograph date unknown.

What the November order restricted

Judge Walter’s preliminary injunction restrained BlueBeat, Media Rights Technologies, Basebeat, Hank Risan and associated parties from infringing the plaintiffs’ recordings through the two websites or otherwise.

The order covered activities including copying, downloading, distributing, transmitting and publicly performing the recordings. It addressed both recordings covered by federal copyright and older recordings protected under the relevant state or common-law rights identified in the order.

The 18 November injunction text describes the restrictions as applying pending trial. It was an interim order in the case, rather than the final resolution of damages.

The psycho-acoustic simulation argument

Risan claimed in court filings that he had re-recorded the music using a process he called “psycho-acoustic simulation”. He argued that the resulting versions incorporated artistic changes and were new recordings.

His explanation described processing commercially purchased CDs and attempting to simulate the way a listener would hear music. EMI disputed that account as a basis for distributing its catalogue.

The preliminary injunction kept restrictions in place despite that argument. Contemporary reporting described the disagreement between the record company and Risan; it did not announce an authorised Beatles download agreement.

News coverage on 19 November

The Associated Press reported that the sites, which had sold Beatles songs for a quarter each, were to remain shut down indefinitely. The report identified the injunction against BlueBeat and Basebeat and explained that a hearing had originally been scheduled for Friday.

Coverage on 19 November followed the Wednesday order. The distinction between the two dates explains why this development appears in a 19 November Beatles timeline while the court document is dated 18 November.

The official iTunes release came later

The Beatles’ authorised iTunes launch followed on 16 November 2010, through an announcement by Apple Corps, EMI and Apple. It was a separate commercial agreement from the disputed BlueBeat service.

Read The Beatles arrive on iTunes for that later release. Apple Corps was the Beatles’ company; Apple operated iTunes.

For the music behind the catalogue, explore our Abbey Road guide, covering the album whose Apple label is pictured above.

Explore Beatles Apple-logo designs

Discover clothing celebrating the Beatles’ Apple identity in the Beatles Apple collection.

Apple Logo grey pullover hoodie

Explore the grey Apple Logo pullover hoodie and choose your size on the product page.

The Beatles Apple Logo grey unisex pullover hoodie

Apple Logo grey T-shirt

Discover the grey Apple Logo unisex T-shirt for another design connected with the Beatles’ record-label history.

The Beatles Apple Logo grey unisex T-shirt

Frequently asked questions

What was reported on 19 November 2009?

A preliminary injunction continued restrictions on BlueBeat and Basebeat distributing EMI recordings, including Beatles songs.

When was the injunction issued?

The court order was dated 18 November 2009.

Who was the judge?

US District Judge John F. Walter.

How much did the sites charge for Beatles tracks?

The advertised price was 25 US cents per track.

Was this the final judgment in the case?

No. It was a preliminary injunction applying pending trial.

When did the Beatles officially arrive on iTunes?

On 16 November 2010, through an agreement announced by Apple Corps, EMI and Apple.


November archive | On This Day | Beatles Knowledge Hub

0 comments

Leave a comment